Litigation terms
Daubert standard
The Daubert standard is the framework federal courts (and most states) use to gatekeep expert testimony — reliability and fit, assessed through factors like testability, peer review, error rates, and general acceptance.
Daubert v. Merrell Dow (1993) made trial judges gatekeepers of expert reliability; Kumho Tire extended the duty beyond science to all expert testimony. Federal Rule of Evidence 702 — amended in 2023 to sharpen the point — requires the proponent to show it more likely than not that the testimony rests on sufficient facts, reliable principles, and a reliable application to the case. A minority of states retain the older Frye general-acceptance test.
Why it matters in practice
Daubert motions are won on the record more often than on epistemology. The classic winning angles are concrete: the expert’s opinion assumes facts the record contradicts; the methodology was applied selectively (the treating records that cut against causation went uncited); the error rate exists but was never mentioned; the opinion appeared for litigation and nowhere in the expert’s professional life. The 2023 amendment aimed squarely at “the expert said so” overstatement — opinions must stay within what the method and data support.
That makes expert-report review a fact-checking exercise: every “the records demonstrate” line is a claim with a checkable citation, and the ones that don’t check out become the motion’s spine.
In the fact record
Auditing an expert’s factual predicate against the file is mechanical when the file is already extracted and cited — each assertion in the report either matches a verified fact or it doesn’t, and the mismatches are the Daubert exhibit list.