Skip to content
F·M FactMarshal
Menu
← Glossary

Litigation terms

Demand letter

A demand letter is the pre-suit settlement package sent to a liable party or insurer — liability theory, injuries, treatment, damages, and a number — and in injury practice, the document most cases actually resolve on.

Updated

The injury-practice demand assembles the whole claim: facts and liability, medical narrative keyed to the records, itemized specials (bills, wage loss), general-damages argument, and the demand figure — often with exhibits attached. Time-limited policy-limits demands add a deadline and acceptance terms, setting up bad-faith exposure if the insurer mishandles them.

Why it matters in practice

Adjusters audit demands against the records, so the letter’s credibility is a records-accuracy question. Every date, provider, diagnosis, and dollar in the narrative will be checked against the chart and bills; an overclaimed injury or a mischaracterized visit discounts the entire package. The strongest demands anticipate the file’s weaknesses — the treatment gap, the prior complaint — and address them rather than hoping they go unnoticed.

Two drafting cautions. Demands are generally inadmissible as settlement communications (FRE 408), but factual assertions have ways of resurfacing — plaintiffs get cross-examined on demand-letter claims that conflict with testimony in some courts, and misstatements burn credibility with the adjuster regardless. And a demand sent before the medical picture stabilizes prices the claim on incomplete information.

In the fact record

A demand is a rendering of the fact record — chronology, verified specials, addressed weaknesses. Building it from a record where every assertion carries its citation is the difference between a package an adjuster can audit and one they can attack.