Skip to content
F·M FactMarshal
Menu
← Glossary

Litigation terms

Proximate cause

Proximate cause is the legal limit on liability for the consequences of negligence — beyond but-for causation, the harm must be a foreseeable result of the conduct rather than the product of a broken causal chain.

Updated

Causation has two parts. Cause in fact asks the but-for question (or, with multiple sufficient causes, whether the conduct was a substantial factor). Proximate cause asks the policy question: is this harm close enough — foreseeable enough — to hold the defendant responsible? The law-school landmark is Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad; the operative doctrines are foreseeability and superseding cause, the intervening event so abnormal it breaks the chain.

Why it matters in practice

In injury litigation the proximate-cause fight usually wears medical clothing. The defense builds alternative-cause narratives from the record: the degenerative findings that predate the crash, the second accident between injury and surgery, the non-compliance that worsened the outcome. The plaintiff builds continuity: a quiet baseline, symptoms beginning at the incident, an unbroken treatment arc connecting event to damages. The eggshell-plaintiff rule guards severity (a defendant takes the victim as found), but it doesn’t supply the causal link — the chart has to.

That makes causation a chronology contest. The side that can put the sequence — every symptom onset, every finding, every intervening event — on one dated, cited line usually controls the narrative.

In the fact record

Superseding-cause candidates are timeline features: they sit between incident and outcome. A complete treatment chronology exposes them early — to be addressed by the plaintiff or weaponized by the defense, but ambushing no one.